Plucky Tree
  • Home
  • About This Site
  • Contact me
  • Search Icon
Civil discourse and “tone”

Civil discourse and “tone”

2010-09-20

Often when people get into a vigorous debate of ideas, especially with those that disagree with them, it gets derailed by someone complaining about the “tone” of the debate or pleading for “civil discourse”.

As usual, Glenn Greenwald has a brilliant summation of this issue:

“One other point about this fixation on the “tone” of our politics. Political debates are inherently acrimonious – much of the rhetoric during the time of the American Founding, as well as throughout the 19th Century, easily competes with, if not exceeds, what we have now in terms of noxiousness and extremity – but far more important than tone, in my view, is content. I don’t think anyone disputes that our discourse would benefit if it were more substantive and rational, but it’s usually the ideas themselves – not the tone used to express them – that are the culprits.“

If only that could fit on a bumper sticker!

This is one of the things that always troubled me about politics in Washington. When people that have a conscience want to object to endless wars, hypocrisy, and mountains of debt for future generations, I don’t expect them to be civil. I expect them to kick some ass.

While people die, we have politicians worried that our debate might hurt someone’s feelings.

Related Posts:

  • How Jimmy Carter saved beer
    How Jimmy Carter saved beer

politics

Post navigation

NEXT
How Jimmy Carter saved beer
PREVIOUS
AP has some actual journalistic principles

Get Monthly Updates

Recent Posts

  • Our “groundbreaking” garden
  • A very long review of Portland
  • Burger King realizations
  • Tennis meteors
  • 2021 in words, pictures, and movies

Categories

  • annual letter (2)
  • apple (2)
  • birds (3)
  • capitalism (3)
  • censorship (1)
  • economics (3)
  • education (1)
  • food (1)
  • freedom (1)
  • health (5)
  • internet (2)
  • local (2)
  • media (6)
  • meta (1)
  • music (4)
  • new zealand (2)
  • peace (1)
  • philanthropy (2)
  • photos (2)
  • politics (2)
  • satire (2)
  • shopping (1)
  • silly (1)
  • steve jobs (1)
  • stock market (1)
  • tennis (8)
  • think of the children (2)
  • travel (3)
  • Uncategorized (1)
  • writing (1)

Get Monthly Updates

About Me


I’ve been a bird breeder, a bicycle mechanic, bookseller, and a Software Engineer at Apple for 20 years.

Friends tell me I have interesting things to say.

You be the judge.

My Other Blogs

  • Free Range Parrots
  • Tech Reflect
© 2022   All Rights Reserved.